The Catholic Voter: Trump, Vance and the 2024 Election in Focus!
Guest lecture by Prof. Dr. Massimo Faggioli at the University of Münster on May 27, 2025 about the influence of Catholicism in the USA.

The Catholic Voter: Trump, Vance and the 2024 Election in Focus!
On May 27th, Prof. Dr. Massimo Faggioli will give an important guest lecture at the Catholic Theological Faculty of the University of Münster. The topic of his lecture is: "The New Catholic Moment in the USA. From the 1980s to Donald Trump". Faggioli, who has been a professor of historical theology at Villanova University since 2016, will classify current (church) political debates in the USA reported that. The lecture begins at 7:30 p.m. in the lecture hall KTh I, Johannisstraße 8–10 and is open to the public.
Massimo Faggioli, born in Italy in 1970 and studying theology in Tübingen, among other places, is considered an expert on the history of the Second Vatican Council. He classifies topics such as the post-conciliar papacy, global Catholicism, and the internal dynamics of the Catholic Church in the United States. Faggioli is also a critical voice towards US right-wing Catholicism, particularly the person of J. D. Vance. Vance, who converted to Catholicism in 2019, was nominated by Donald Trump as his vice presidential running mate. This development is particularly explosive because the US bishops are politically divided and many of them supported Trump because of his anti-abortion stance katholisch.de highlights.
The division of the Catholic electorate
Since the late 1970s, the Catholic electorate in the United States has been politically divided. Faggioli emphasizes the crucial role Catholics play in key states. This group could now be significantly influenced by the withdrawal of Joe Biden, the incumbent president and the Democratic presidential candidate. Kamala Harris, the vice president, is already being touted as a possible successor, particularly on the controversial issue of abortion katholisch.de shows how important this issue will be in the election campaign.
The dynamics within the Catholic community are shaped not only by internal disputes, but also by the larger political environment in which US religious policy is becoming increasingly unpredictable. Religious voter groups, including Protestants, are losing members, while the number of non-religious people, also known as “nones,” is continually increasing. In this context, the Catholic electorate, which makes up about 21% of the US population, plays a more stable and crucial role for both major parties.
Trump's political agenda and its consequences
With Biden's withdrawal, Pope Francis has lost an important conversation partner. This development shows that American Catholicism is no longer exclusively conservative and uniform, but is in the process of change. J. D. Vance is described as an anti-liberal Catholic whose contact with Trump's course and whose religious rhetoric after the Trump assassination attempt is considered problematic reports katholisch.de.
Donald Trump is launching his campaign for the 2024 presidential election under different conditions compared to 2016. His campaign team has undergone numerous changes and strategists are trying to ensure domestic stability after Trump's first term left rifts in alliances explains katholisch.de. In this difficult environment, Trump's re-election could bring not only democratic regression but also the danger of a theocratic agenda.
The Catholic electorate appears to be becoming increasingly polarized in this political vortex, presenting both challenges and opportunities for parties. The upcoming election campaign is crucial for the future of the Catholic community and its influence on US politics.